
It started as the best month ever. Coming off our TV special, our buddy “Bob,” mega-publisher Robert Petersen, booked my band The Daily Planet for our first Big Gig (no dancing teenagers shouting “play something we know!”) at the Motor Trend Car Show in San Diego. We’d play our own stuff and be paid way more than “fifty-bucks-and-all-the-punch-you-can-drink.”
We didn’t love it when our opening act’s manager Fiona informed us we’d be backing up her “fast-rising country star” protégé. One of whose cover songs, “Harper Valley PTA,” was pretty near the top of our rock-n-roll-suicide list. But we sucked it up and picked-and-grinned our way through the poodle-haired singer’s set.
We did love it, however, when Fiona approached us afterward and offered us a management contract that guaranteed…our first album! It would be no time at all now, mere microseconds compared to the age of the universe, before we were proclaimed “the next Beatles!”
When we got home, we signed up for the final concert of the season at our town’s Garden Hill Park amphitheater. Determined to blow our audience’s minds, we decided to conclude with the aptly-titled tune “Blowin’ Our Minds.” We passed out percussion instruments and invited the audience to join in. Led by our phenomenal drummer Joey, they clapped and maraca-ed, bongoed and tambourined, cow-belled and claved their way to the end, and then cheered as we left the stage and rushed back for an encore.
My girlfriend Marty and I had barely seen each other since starting school at two different colleges. We’d gone through a rough patch during the summer when I told her, clueless to the disparities between infatuation and love, “I don’t feel the same anymore.” Later, realizing my love was simply evolving, I asked her to forget what I’d said.
So when she approached, eyes glistening, after the concert, I assumed we’d be doing some serious make-up snogging. Instead, she stroked my hair, and said, “I don’t feel the same anymore…”
“Oh, hey, but that’s just—”
“And I’m in love with someone else,” she concluded. I felt like I’d created the hole that made the dam burst. But, in retrospect, we’d been seventeen, in love for the first time, and then started moving in different directions, meeting different people.
Sadly, Marty’s new love was a fascinatingly moody older guy who was still “technically” married. He was also technically an alcoholic, and for a time her yearning to fix him had felt like love. Later, I heard, after my good little church girl managed to disentangle herself from him, she was crushed and ashamed. But by then we were out of each other’s lives.
The following month, Judy Collins’ version of “Both Sides Now” was released, introducing me to a songwriter, Joni Mitchell, who would become one of my biggest musical influences. It also introduced me to lost love. I can never hear these words…
I’ve looked at love from both sides now
From give and take, and still somehow
It’s love’s illusions, I recall
I really don’t know love at all…
Without thinking of Marty.
My Real Memoir is a series. To read the next one, click here.

Pingback: Starting to Lose My Way | Mitch Teemley
My heart breaks for the young you.
Epic teen love story; mountains and valleys.
Indeed.
Your band’s concert at the Garden Hill Park amphitheater sounds like it was infectious fun for both your band and your audience. Performing definitely was and is in your blood. 🙂
Yep. It was and, as you say, is, Nancy.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8L1UngfqojI
Judy Collins “Both Sides Now”
Bittersweet memories.
Wow. Joy and sadness = life.
Yep.
This is so deeply insightful, Mitch. Though I knew your relationship with Martha had its ups and downs, I never knew the details. I have to wonder if everyone had that ‘first love’ experience, I know I did…though the story is different, the lessons were much the same. Not sure how this strikes you (especially as a man 😅), but the first word that came to mind at the end was ‘precious!’ Truly! ♥️
Our lives have mirrored one another in quite a few ways, haven’t they, Dori.
Most certainly… regular people on this journey to live the life we were created for in Jesus. And a journey it has been!
Reminded me of all those mistakes with my first love those many years ago.
Pingback: Me and Princess Leia’s Mom | Mitch Teemley
Pingback: How I Lost My Innocence | Mitch Teemley
Pingback: Flying High Into the New Year | Mitch Teemley
Pingback: The Greatest Album No One’s Ever Heard | Mitch Teemley
Pingback: Love and Stroganoff | Mitch Teemley
Pingback: Flying Out of Control | Mitch Teemley
Pingback: In With a Shout, Out With a Whimper | Mitch Teemley
Pingback: Looking for a Bigger Love | Mitch Teemley
Pingback: The Long and Winding Road | Mitch Teemley
Pingback: The Girl Whose Brain I Loved | Mitch Teemley
Pingback: Falling in Love With Falling in Love | Mitch Teemley
Pingback: Longing to Fly | Mitch Teemley
Pingback: Out of the Frying Pan… | Mitch Teemley
Pingback: A Fake Life | Mitch Teemley
Pingback: Looking for a Bigger Love - Mitch Teemley
Pingback: Looking for Love and the Meaning of Life - Mitch Teemley
Pingback: My Hunger for an Abiding Love - Mitch Teemley